Mimetic desire, as defined by René Girard (1923–2015), a French historian, literary critic, and philosopher, refers to the unconscious imitation of the desires of others. Rather than originating from within, our desires are influenced by external models—people we observe or admire. We often want something not because of its inherent value, but because someone else desires it. This imitative nature of desire leads to rivalry, conflict, and competition as multiple people chase after the same objects, statuses, or goals. Girard’s theory of mimetic desire reveals a hidden mechanism shaping human behavior and culture, with deep implications for how we live and relate to one another.
René Girard’s theory of mimetic desire offers a profound and often unsettling insight into human nature. At its core, the theory suggests that human beings are inherently imitative; our desires are shaped by others, rather than arising from within us. This framework has far-reaching consequences for understanding our behavior, relationships, and society at large. By exploring both the practical and philosophical implications of mimetic desire, we can uncover strategies for living a life that is more self-aware, ethical, and aligned with personal happiness.
Mimetic Desire in Life
On a practical level, mimetic desire plays a central role in shaping the choices we make, often without our realizing it. From the products we buy to the careers we pursue, we are often influenced by what we see others doing or desiring. Advertisements, social media, peer groups, and even family members serve as models, guiding our desires in subtle and profound ways.
Consumerism and Materialism
In modern consumer culture, mimetic desire fuels much of the competition for status and wealth. We often seek out possessions not because of their inherent utility or value, but because they are desired or owned by others. This desire can lead to a never-ending cycle of acquisition and dissatisfaction. We mimic the desires of influencers, celebrities, or even our neighbors, continually upgrading our lifestyle in an effort to keep up with those around us.
Career and Social Standing
Similarly, in our professional lives, we often imitate the ambitions and goals of those we admire. People may chase promotions, career paths, or social status because these things are desired by others in their network or field. This can lead to career dissatisfaction when individuals pursue external markers of success rather than their own passions or talents.
Relationships and Rivalry
Girard’s theory also applies to interpersonal relationships, where mimetic desire can breed rivalry and jealousy. Romantic, familial, or social relationships can become fraught with tension as individuals vie for the same affections or social standing. Mimetic desire can often obscure authentic connections, replacing them with competitive dynamics that foster resentment.
Philosophical Implications of Mimetic Desire
Mimetic desire is not just a social phenomenon; it raises deeper philosophical questions about freedom, authenticity, and ethics. If our desires are fundamentally shaped by others, to what extent are we truly autonomous? Girard’s theory challenges the idea of an independent self, suggesting that much of our identity is built through imitation.
The Illusion of Autonomy
One of the key philosophical implications of mimetic desire is the questioning of free will and autonomy. If our desires are not fully our own but are borrowed from others, then our sense of self-determination is compromised. Girard’s theory suggests that we are not as free in our choices as we might think. Instead, we are deeply embedded in networks of influence that shape our behavior.
The Ethics of Desire
Girard’s theory also forces us to confront the ethical dimensions of desire. If much of human conflict arises from imitation, then how do we manage the negative consequences of our competitive tendencies? Philosophically, mimetic desire highlights the need for greater self-awareness and ethical reflection. Understanding the imitative nature of desire can help individuals recognize when their actions are driven by envy or rivalry, rather than genuine motivations.
The Scapegoat Mechanism and Social Cohesion
One of Girard’s most controversial ideas is the notion of the scapegoat mechanism, where communities resolve internal conflicts by uniting against an individual or group. This scapegoating process has historical, religious, and social implications, as it reveals how societies often use violence or exclusion to maintain order. On a philosophical level, it raises questions about justice, fairness, and how societies manage conflict.
Living a Happy and Ethical Life Free From Mimetic Desire
Given the pervasive influence of mimetic desire, how can one live a life that is both happy and consistent with one’s ethics and principles? Girard’s insights suggest several strategies for cultivating a more authentic and fulfilling life, one that is less driven by imitative desires and more aligned with personal values.
Cultivate Self-Awareness
The first step in countering the negative effects of mimetic desire is to become aware of it. By reflecting on the sources of our desires, we can distinguish between those that arise from imitation and those that reflect our authentic interests. Meditation, journaling, or therapy can help individuals explore the deeper motivations behind their actions. Recognizing when we are driven by the desire to mimic others is key to breaking the cycle of competition and dissatisfaction.
Focus on Intrinsic Desires
Living a happy and ethical life requires shifting focus from external desires (which are often mimetic) to intrinsic ones. Intrinsic desires are those that are personally meaningful, not based on what others value or seek. This might involve pursuing hobbies, career paths, or relationships that bring personal fulfillment, rather than those that boost social status or are fashionable. By cultivating intrinsic desires, individuals can lead more authentic lives, driven by their own sense of purpose and joy.
Embrace Non-Competitive Models
Girard’s theory suggests that competition arises when individuals imitate the same desires. One way to avoid rivalry is to choose models of desire that are not competitive. Instead of seeking material wealth, social status, or power, individuals can look to models who embody qualities like generosity, creativity, or wisdom. These are desires that do not lead to rivalry because they are not zero-sum.
Practice Empathy and Forgiveness
One of the darker sides of mimetic desire is the tendency toward rivalry and scapegoating. To live an ethical life, individuals can consciously practice empathy and forgiveness, seeking to resolve conflicts without turning others into scapegoats. By recognizing that others are also subject to the pressures of mimetic desire, we can develop greater compassion for their struggles and avoid falling into cycles of blame or resentment.
Cultivate Community and Shared Goals
Rather than competing with others for individual desires, Girard’s theory suggests that social cohesion can be maintained by focusing on shared goals and communal values. This might involve participating in groups or communities that prioritize cooperation, mutual support, and collective well-being over individual competition. Whether in the context of work, friendships, or civic engagement, seeking out opportunities for collaboration rather than competition can lead to more fulfilling and ethical relationships.
René Girard’s theory of mimetic desire offers a powerful lens through which to understand human behavior, both on an individual and societal level. Its implications are profound, challenging the notion of free will and highlighting the competitive nature of human desire. However, by cultivating self-awareness, focusing on intrinsic goals, and practicing empathy, individuals can navigate the challenges posed by mimetic desire and live lives that are both ethically sound and personally fulfilling. In recognizing the influence of imitation, we gain the freedom to choose more authentic paths, leading to an ethical and happier life that is aligned with our deepest values and aspirations.
Recommended Literature
René Girard’s key works essential for deepening understanding of his theory of mimetic desire and its implications:
1. “Deceit, Desire, and the Novel: Self and Other in Literary Structure” (1961)
In this seminal work, Girard first introduces the concept of mimetic desire by analyzing major works of literature, such as those by Cervantes, Stendhal, Flaubert, Proust, and Dostoevsky. He explores how characters' desires are shaped by others and how this leads to conflict and self-deception.
2. “Violence and the Sacred” (1972)
This book explores how human societies deal with violence through rituals, religion, and the scapegoat mechanism. Girard examines how sacrificial systems function to control and limit the violence generated by mimetic rivalry.
3. “Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World” (1978)
One of Girard’s most comprehensive works, this book outlines his full theory of mimetic desire, the scapegoat mechanism, and the role of sacrifice in human culture. Girard also discusses the biblical text as a critique of these social mechanisms.
4. “The Scapegoat” (1982)
Girard further develops his theory of the scapegoat mechanism, analyzing historical events, myths, and religious rituals where societies project their violence onto a single individual or group in order to restore order.
5. “I See Satan Fall Like Lightning” (1999)
In this book, Girard discusses how the Christian Gospels reveal and critique the mechanisms of mimetic desire and scapegoating. He argues that Christianity unveils the violent foundations of human culture and offers a new way of understanding human relationships.
6. “The One by Whom Scandal Comes” (2001)
Girard explores the concept of scandal, particularly how human beings become entangled in mimetic rivalry through envy and imitation, and how this leads to social breakdown.
7. “Evolution and Conversion: Dialogues on the Origins of Culture” (2007)
This work takes the form of a dialogue, in which Girard discusses the evolution of human culture and the role of mimetic desire in shaping social and religious structures.
8. “Battling to the End: Conversations with Benoît Chantre” (2007)
In this book, Girard reflects on war, politics, and the apocalyptic nature of violence in the modern world, linking these themes to his theory of mimetic desire and rivalry.
These works provide the theoretical foundation for exploring mimetic desire and its profound philosophical, ethical, and practical implications. They are essential reading for anyone interested in Girard's ideas on human nature, conflict, and society.
Artwork
Infinite Self
The Frontier Man
July 2024